New Sports Betting Sites in Indiana 2023

List of the Best New Indiana Betting Sites 2023

Indiana currently has over a dozen top bookies, and more are coming. Since the state legalized sports betting, there has been a continuous upward trend in new additions each year. So, we can expect to see new Indiana betting sites compete for the already booming market.

Before we shortlist any of these new sites, we take our time to do a background check. In the next section, we will share details about our review process and criteria to help you understand our selections.

Five Things Every New Indiana Betting Site Should Have

Of course, more than five things make an online betting site work. However, we cannot discuss all of them, so we narrowed it down to a few. Our review process is comprehensive and could sometimes take months. Indeed, while we advise every player to evaluate new betting sites before registering, it is not a task for the uninitiated. It is crucial that you know where to look, and that is why we have come up with these five top features that every new Indiana betting site should have.

1. Proper License and Responsible Gaming

The online gambling industry is a very vulnerable space. Players can access betting sites from anywhere without restrictions which can be very challenging. Although most Indiana betting sites use a Geolocation sensor tool to ensure that players are physically located in the state, many shady sites do not comply with these requirements. These bookies do not have any authorization, or if they do, it is usually an offshore license.

Hence, one of the most crucial things every New Indiana betting site must have is a valid license from the Indiana Gaming Commission. So, just because a site accepts players from Indiana does not mean it has approval from the IGC. Ensure that you check and verify that the license is valid.

Also, look out for responsible gaming tools that help players manage their activities. Check for self-exclusion options, links to support groups, reality checks, and deposit limits. Indeed, every sportsbook with a valid license must have these features, so the next time you see one without it, that’s a red flag.

2. A Decent Amount of Payment Methods

Every new betting site must provide reliable and secure payment options. While there are so many payment gateways globally, players are more confident when they see familiar names. Popular e-wallets like PayPal, Neteller, and Skrill are a huge plus for any new betting site. These options are fast, secure, and easy to use.

Similarly, many players like to stick to their old ways of traditional payments. Some prefer to use a physical location to fund their account. So, if this is you, then you need a sportsbook that supports PayNearMe. That way, you can fund your account from approved outlets across the state. Moreover, if you prefer credit/debit cards, you need betting sites that support American Express, Visa, Mastercard, Paysafecard, and many other options.

3. Reliable Customer Service

Customer service is crucial for every sportsbook. It’s important that players can communicate with the support team with ease. So, we review the available channels, the response time, and the overall quality of the services.

Most new sportsbooks integrate modern support tools like live chat and telephone support. These features allow instant access and real-time communication with an experienced support agent. For each site we review, we use every tool. We send messages to the support agents and check the response time many times before concluding. Likewise, we ask many questions and check for the quality of their response and overall performance in helping resolve an issue.

Meanwhile, every site has a dedicated FAQ section which is important. We review the questions and answers to see if it is sufficient.

4. Competitive Odds & Generous Promotions

The lower the odds, the higher the possibility of securing a win. Indeed, you do not want to use a bookie constantly offering lower odds below the market average. Instead, we search for the top bookies who are very generous to offer competitive odds. For every major event, we compare the odds on many top sites, which can go on for months before we conclude.

We also understand that bonuses can boost your finances and improve your chances of winning. Therefore, we check the various types of offers available on a site. Starting with the welcome bonus, we review the amount to see if it is worth it. We also check the minimum qualifying deposit required to activate the offer, the wagering requirements, and the validity period.

We also understand that you want more than just a one-time welcome bonus. So, we check for top sites that offer a loyalty scheme, cashback, and other fantastic rewards.

5. A Variety of Sports and Betting Options

Most top betting sites provide thousands of pre-match betting options each month. Usually, the events are drawn from more than3 sports, usually from popular ones like football, cricket, baseball, hockey, basketball, tennis, and boxing.

Meanwhile, many new Indiana betting sites focus more on the US markets for these sports selections. From college events to professional leagues, you will find thousands of betting markets. The most popular choices come from the NFL, NASCAR, ATP, NBA, MLB, MLS, and many more.

Notwithstanding, some sites offer thousands of options from other competitors outside the US, which is excellent. We look for a sportsbook covering events from the UEFA Champions League, UEFA Europa League, Indian Premier League (cricket), Spanish La Liga, English Premier League, and many others.

Bonuses at New Indiana Sportsbooks

Following the legalization of sports betting in Indiana, many sportsbooks have entered the market, providing a range of betting options and promotions to attract players. Meanwhile, many new sites are also in the pipeline making the market very competitive.

Bonuses play a crucial role in attracting players to make their selections. Almost every bookie offers a welcome bonus. However, there is more, and in the next section, we will take a closer look at the various types of rewards you can expect to see at New Indiana sportsbooks.

Deposit or Welcome Bonus

The welcome bonus is one of the most common offers you will find on any Indiana betting site. It is an incentive designed to lure new players into using a sportsbook. Once you visit any betting site, it is usually one of the first and most prominent things you will see.

Most welcome bonuses require a qualifying deposit to unlock them. This is why it is often referred to as a deposit bonus by many players. For example, a sportsbook may offer a welcome bonus of 100% up to $1,000 to new members.

The deposit bonus comes with many terms and conditions, and often, players skip that part. As professionals, we check everything to ensure the offer is not restrictive. It is essential to compare offers on other sites to see which one is the best. Look out for restrictions on the payment methods that can be used to activate the offer and if the bonus can be used on all sports. Some sites limit the sports and betting markets to a few options once you use the bonus. Above all, check the wagering requirement and how much time you have to complete it.

No Deposit Bonus

No deposit bonus also belongs to the category of welcome bonuses, except that you do not need any deposit to activate it. Sometimes, the offer can be tied to the original deposit bonus as free bets. So, you can have a bookie offering a 100% matchup bonus of up to $200 plus $10 free bets.

No deposit bonuses are usually small and direct. You usually unlock the reward once your account registration is complete. Meanwhile, it comes with many restrictions, which might make you want to reconsider, considering the amount is small. There may be restrictions on the type of sports and odds you can bet.

Reload Bonus

Reload bonus targets existing players and encourages them to make additional deposits, especially after the first one. The idea is to ensure that new payers live beyond the aura of the first deposit bonus. So, some betting sites offer a special reload bonus on the second deposit and, sometimes, more.

For example, a new betting site may offer a 50% reload bonus of up to $100 on your second and third consecutive deposits. You will get the amount if you keep to the rules, especially if you must deposit within a particular timeframe. Meanwhile, the offer also has its requirements, so checking before you opt-in is best.

VIP Program

While the welcome bonus targets new players, the VIP program aims at rewarding loyalty. So, if you continue to use the same sportsbook over time, you will qualify for the VIP scheme and earn unique rewards.

The scheme is usually in different levels, between five and eight. Every player automatically falls into the first level. However, to level up, you must earn the required points. The VIP loyalty points are a function of your wagers and deposits. The more money you bet, the more points you accumulate, the higher your ranking and, eventually, your rewards. Some of the popular offers from the VIP scheme include:

• Exclusive invites to VIP events
• VIP cashback rewards
• Personalized offers and free bets
• Birthday and anniversary offer
• Higher transaction limits
• Personal account manager

Red Flags to Watch Out for at New Betting Sites in Indiana

Before you sign up for a new sportsbook, ensure that you also check for some potential red flags that could indicate that it is unreliable. Below are some key features to be on the lookout for:

No License

We have often said that when a bookie does not have a permit from the IGC, that’s a red flag. Of course, dozens of international bookmakers are accessible in the state. We advise you to stay away from these sites. Therefore, scroll up and select one of the new Indiana sportsbooks from our list. These sites are all reputable and have the IGC seal of approval.

Poor Reputation

If a new betting site already has terrible customer reviews, that’s a bad sign. New bookies are supposed to offer a fresh start with modern betting tools. So, ensure you check top reviewing sites before using a new sportsbook. We read all player reviews we can find during our testing process and use this info as one of the criteria when making our top picks.

Limited Payment Options 

You need all the variety of banking options on a site to make the best choice. If a new sportsbook only features very few payment options, that’s a bad sign. One of the most important elements of a good sports betting experience is the possibility to choose the payment method you prefer. So, if the sportsbook just has a few, this is not a very good sign.

Most Popular Sports at New Betting Sites in Indiana

The most popular sports on Indiana betting sites are football, basketball, soccer, baseball, tennis, and cricket. Although the market focuses on US leagues, you will find events from other top global competitions. There are thousands of betting options from the MMA, MLS, NFL, NBA, MLB, and many others.

Many residents have a natural affection for football to support their team, the Indianapolis Colts. Likewise, in other competitions, Indiana boasts top teams like the Chicago Cubs, Cincinnati Reds, and the Pacers. You can never run out of choices with all of these options, coupled with selections from the English Premier League, French Ligue 1, Spanish La Liga, and other competitions.

New Betting Sites vs. Old Sportsbook: What’s Better?

New betting sites come with the most recent innovations, while old sportsbooks have a rich experience and reputation. Indeed, the choice depends on individual preference but below is a summary of our comparison.

Pros & Cons of New Indiana Betting Sites

Pros

• Attractive bonuses and promotions
• More intuitive and interactive design
• Competitive odds
• More payment options

Cons

• Questionable history and reputation
• Limited betting options
• Unclear regulations

Frequently Asked Questions About New Betting Sites in Indiana