Best Sports Betting Sites in New Jersey 2024

This Is How We Review US Betting Sites

As you can see above, our list is full of standout candidates. However, you might not agree with the placement or even some selections. That’s why Gambla wants you to know our review process. Therefore, our experts decided to give you a rundown of what our research involves. Of course, you can try these steps yourself and ensure a site is good, too.

History and Safety Checks 

We’re not interested just in the current situation. Sure, everyone wants the current best New Jersey betting sites, but that’s not the whole story. Sometimes, a bookie might seem good, only to end up unproven and dishonest. That’s why Gambla does an extensive check for every candidate.

We do background checks on the operator, as well as double-check the license. But checking the track record is perhaps even more important. Naturally, if there aren’t any scandals or controversies, then we can move onwards.

Real Money Deposit and Withdrawal Options

Each New Jersey betting site review involves manual banking tests. Specifically, our team members create an account each as they try out different payment methods. In addition to depositing and withdrawing, we also compare the process to other sites. Are deposits instant? How long do you have to wait for withdrawals? Are there any fees? These are just some of the questions we want answers to.

Checking Available Sports and Odds Testing

If banking and reputation are in line with our expectations, it’s time for sports. First and foremost, we want to see what’s the variety in this department. Sure, major US leagues are important, but what about other things? This includes European leagues, winter sports and all kinds of niche competitions.

Claiming NJ Betting Site Bonuses and Wager Testing

As part of the banking test, we also test bonuses at New Jersey betting sites. But before we claim them, we comprehensively analyze the T&C. We want to see if there are any limitations, hidden costs or obstacles. In addition, Gambla compares the rollover requirements to other sites. Then, we rank the bonus after testing it. Bonus points go to promos that are unique, fun and non-restrictive.

Conducting a Not Approved List Scan

We’ve always had a blacklist for NJ bookies. It’s rare, but there are times when bookies abuse the players’ trust. Things such as withheld payments and unlawful account shutdowns are unforgivable. That’s why we run every new bookie against this not approved list. If there are any instances of shady behavior, the site is excluded from our rankings, period.

Sending For Approval and Ranking with Our Quality Team

One of the secrets to Gambla’s success is our multi-layered approach. Instead of letting one person do it, multiple members of our team conduct the review. But then, they send their impressions to the quality team. They verify the information, crunch the numbers and rank the sites. In addition, this same team is tasked with keeping the ranking up to date.

Betting Site Gets Added to Our Ranked Toplist

Of course, this isn’t the entire process for reviewing New Jersey sports betting sites. There are also multiple checks, some of them including input from our industry contacts. And once everything has been settled, Gambla decides the right placement for the site. Again, our rankings are always dynamic. So, any improvements or blunders will receive the appropriate reaction.

We Compare the Top New Jersey Betting Sites

Another unique thing about Gambla’s review method are comparisons. Many of our competitors look at bookies in a vacuum. We disagree with this approach, as it overlooks many important factors. It also ignores improvements and scandals that might implicate a bookie. Just because a site was good yesterday doesn’t mean it’ll top our lists tomorrow. To keep things up to date, we use these aspects for comparing New Jersey betting sites:

• Free bets. These are special promos for both new and existing players. Instead of getting money, you can place a bet without paying. Of course, there are limits on the size of the wager, as well as the maximum winnings.
• Odds. Gambla’s rankings are the result of long-term monitoring. Our team picks a few big events, and we see how each bookie performs. If a site consistently offers good lines, they’ll get bonus points.
• College football. Whether it’s bowl games or weirder matchups, we want to see a lot of NCAAF. And we don’t mean just basic money lines and over/under. The best New Jersey betting sites have an extensive collection of props, futures, and more.
• Betting bonuses. First and foremost, these promos should have value. But Gambla is mainly focused on fair bonuses that are easy to claim. No matter how much money you’re getting, it should be without too many restrictions.

We Include Only the Best NJ Online Betting Sites

Oftentimes, our readers ask us about what makes the best New Jersey betting sites so good. At first glance, this seems like a classic case of subjective opinion. But throughout our years of reviewing sportsbooks, we’ve seen a pattern. Most of the time, the top betting sites possess these qualities:

• Bonus features. One thing all great legal NJ sportsbooks have in common is going the extra mile. This means things such as live stream, real-time stats and lots of props.
• Reliable support. All the top New Jersey betting sites have a live chat and email support. And in some cases, you might see phone lines or dedicated social media accounts.
• User-friendly design. Both beginners and experienced players should be able to use the site with ease. It must be easy on the eyes, above all else.
• Player-friendly limits. The limits for deposits and withdrawals must be high, but also flexible. This is so both rookies and high-rollers from NJ can play comfortably.

Bonus Offers by Top New Jersey Betting Sites

Legal New Jersey sportsbooks are known for their promos. Whether it’s welcome bonuses, no deposit bonuses or free bets, there’s a lot going on. But not all bonuses are what they seem. In some cases, bookies purposefully create misleading promos. Here’s how you can recognize them:

• The amount is too good to be true. Only VIP and invite-only sites offer thousands. If you see regular NJ betting sites offer this, there has to be a catch.
• The wagering requirements are too high. Although you can’t avoid them, wagering requirements must be reasonable. Anything over 50x is a ripoff, no matter the other benefits or perks.
• Short expiry date. Rushing players is a common tactic in use by online sportsbooks. By giving you just 24 or 48 hours to spend the bonus, they’re nudging you to make rash decisions. Don’t accept anything less than 7 days.
• The rules are complicated. An ideal sports betting bonus for New Jersey players should be simple. There should be a bullet-point list explaining the basics, followed by the Terms & Conditions. The T&C must be understandable, concise and cover everything.

Learn About No Deposit New Jersey Sportsbook Bonuses

In the last couple of years, New Jersey betting sites have been offering no-deposit bonuses. And it’s no wonder they’re a favorite amongst players. But they aren’t as straightforward as they seem. Sure, the money is technically free, but anything else is highly limited. For instance, a $20 no-deposit bonus probably has high wagering requirements or low maximum winnings.

This can severely limit your experience, but it’s expected. Sportsbooks can’t risk losing too much money, so they add extra conditions to their promos. Regardless, no deposit bonuses are still useful. You can use them to test new sites without risk. Check out Gambla’s list for the best New Jersey betting sites with no deposit bonuses.

Spot the Good vs. Bad New Jersey Sports Betting Sites

With so many available New Jersey sportsbooks, it’s hard to weed out the bad ones. Here’s how to make the process easier:

Play at Online Betting Sites in NJ With These Eight Steps

Check out Gambla’s eight-step process and begin your adventure at New Jersey betting sites:

Sign Up with a Licensed Betting Site Operator in NJ

New Jersey betting sites are regulated by the NJ Division of Gaming Enforcement (NJDGE). So, if a sportsbook doesn’t have the seal of approval, that means they’re operating illegally. To avoid getting scammed, stick to Gambla’s top list. All our recommended bookies are 100% legal in New Jersey, with undeniable proof to back up the claim.

Make a Deposit Using Your Preferred Method

Once you’ve created an account, pick a deposit method. Most betting sites accept cards, e-wallets and vouchers. Pick something you’re comfortable with and check for any fees. If everything’s okay, proceed onward.

Consider Using a Deposit Betting Deposit Bonus

You don’t need a bonus, but Gambla highly recommends you use one. They can help you test the site and perhaps place bets on a big event. Most importantly, though – read the Terms & Conditions. Don’t accept anything before knowing the rules.

Play Your Preferred Games/Odds

After your bonus has landed, use it on eligible games. Pick the odds you’re comfortable with and follow the game to see how it ends. If there are any bugs, contact support right away.

Meet the Wagering Requirement if You Used a Bonus

As we said, all bonuses at betting sites in New Jersey have rollover requirements. Check the bonus status on your profile page to see how the process is going. Again, contact support if something seems wrong.

Accept or Decline Email Promotions 

If you want to receive word of the latest promos, sign up for email promos. Just make sure they don’t end up in your spam folder. In some cases, this can lead to exclusive rewards and promo codes.

Prepare ID Card and Utility Bills for Verification Purposes

The NJDGE mandates that all betting sites must have KYC procedures. As a result, you must prove your identity by providing documents. This can be a payment slip, ID card or utility bill. Just upload them to the site, and an employee will review them in a day or two, max.

Cash Out Your Winnings

Now that your identity has been determined, you can claim your winnings. Check to see if you’ve fulfilled the rollover requirements and enter the amount. Click confirm and just wait for the payment to arrive. Congratulations.

Why You Should Use the Top NJ Betting Sites Listed by Gambla

Gambla’s rankings are unique due to a number of factors, including:

• Only proven and reputable sportsbooks. We don’t deal with shady brands without too much available info. If a site is on the list, it’s 100% legal.
• Independent review team. We aren’t affiliated with any of the sites we review, nor do we get paid. As a result, all lists and reviews at Gambla.com are objective. Our experience is the sole factor that influences our judgment.
• Data-driven approach. Using numbers and real-time comparisons, we give all New Jersey betting sites a fair chance. That’s because we don’t let our personal feelings interfere.
• Up-to-date lists. No matter how good a site is, they get tested over and over again. It’s the only way to keep Gambla’s rankings useful.
• Satisfied readers. Players send us emails on a daily basis, praising our no-nonsense attitude. With every message, we become more determined to push on.
• Multiple editing stages. Every review and list go through several stages of quality assurance. Nothing is published without ensuring it meets Gambla’s standards.

Know the Terms When Playing at New Jersey Betting Sites

Never, ever ignore the Terms & Conditions. They contain all the rules and are legally binding. So, once you accept them, there’s no turning back. Whatever your feelings might be, you agreed to the document. If something’s unclear, don’t hesitate to contact support.

Stay Away from Unlicensed Bookmakers

Shady sportsbooks from the Caribbean are a real thing. While they won’t flaunt their lack of license, they’ll certainly try to justify it. Don’t believe some PR story about how they’re a player-first site or something. If there’s no valid license, you have no protection. Be careful and stick to Gambla’s recommendations.

Betting on Your Mobile Phone in NJ

Mobile betting is a large part of our review process. We have plenty of iOS and Android devices on hand. So whichever site we’re reviewing, our team places bets and tests all the features. That way, we can find out if the bookie is consistent or not.

Five Things to Keep in Mind When Joining a New Online Betting Site

1. Choose a Betting Site with Care

Don’t be in a rush. Slowly explore Gambla’s list and pick a New Jersey betting site that suits you. Remember, it’s all about finding a long-term solution.

2. Only Use Your Own Details

Using someone else’s identity or card can be grounds for banning your account. Besides, you might even get in trouble with the authorities.

3. Decide if Claiming a Bonus is Worthwhile

The best bonuses at NJ sportsbooks are both lucrative and fair. But in most cases, you’ll have to make a compromise. In brief, just think about your priorities and needs before making any moves.

4. Only Use Personal Deposit Methods

If your account name and the name on, let’s say, your friend’s PayPal account don’t match, you’ll get in trouble. Don’t be lazy and create your own, lest you want to lose your account.

5. Know When It’s Time to Stop Betting

Sports betting is gambling, no matter how much you strategize. Hence, create a budget, put spending limits on your account and don’t make rash decisions. If you feel like you’re losing control, seek help.

Major League Betting Sites in NJ 

Unlike most other reviewers, the Gambla team knows the New Jersey market well. As such, we know what to focus on to provide the most value to our readers. In this case, this means odds for the Devils, Nets and even the NY Red Bulls. But in general, we like to see plenty of major league markets. Therefore, you can expect our recommended New Jersey betting sites to provide extensive coverage.

Best Betting Sites by US state

• Best Betting Sites in Arizona
• Best Betting Sites in Colorado
• Best Betting Sites in Connecticut
• Best Betting Sites in Illinois
• Best Betting Sites in Indiana
• Best Betting Sites in Iowa
• Best Betting Sites in Kansas
• Best Betting Sites in Louisiana
• Best Betting Sites in Maryland
• Best Betting Sites in Massachusetts
• Best Betting Sites in Michigan
• Best Betting Sites in the US
• Best Betting Sites in New York
• Best Betting Sites in Ohio
• Best Betting Sites in Pennsylvania
• Best Betting Sites in Tennessee
• Best Betting Sites in Virginia
• Best Betting Sites in West Virginia

Frequently Asked Questions About New Jersey Betting Sites